This is the last in a series of six articles that explore the various interactions and outcomes that result from human contact with the urban forest.
This particular article will touch on the roles and responsibilities of city governments, elected and appointed officials, and other non-governmental organizations that are necessary to advance and maintain successful policies, planning and programs that promote and maintain our urban forests. A summary of the benefits of urban forests closes the six-article series.
The Role of Stakeholders
Urban Forestry is a vital component of sustainable communities given the vast and diverse benefits provided by trees and urban forests.
The advancement of cooperative and productive relationships with the following stakeholders is critical to establishing and maintaining successful urban forestry programs in our cities.
Elected Officials – can enact legislation with proactive policies that enable the various governmental departments to implement programs and practices that ensure the growth and overall health of the urban forest for the benefit of urban residents and visitors alike.
Planning Departments – can create master plans, policies and strategies that prioritize the trees and urban forests. Planning departments need to identify incentives for private sector entities to include trees, green spaces and other vegetation as necessary components of their development projects. Also, the development and implementation of conservation easements, “protection in perpetuity’ agreements, legal land trusts, and transfer of development rights programs for the creation and preservation of green space are important ways that planners can advance the proliferation of the urban forest.
Public Works – can advocate the utilization of natural infrastructure in storm water management, energy consumption, and in reduction of the urban heat island effect. Public works departments can also advance the use of natural infrastructure through thoughtful design in, construction and maintenance practices.
Transportation Departments – can advocate tree planting zones in road construction projects, and in the design and construction of urban greenway connections.
Economic Development Departments – can identify incentives for the private sector to include trees and other elements of the urban forest in their projects. Economic development departments can also develop funding programs through which actual landscaping and/or land acquisitions are possible. The quantification of the local economic contributions of trees and urban forests can also be beneficial to further the health of the urban forest. Economic development departments should include trees and green spaces as critical components of any economic development plan.
Parks and Recreation Departments – can capitalize on their inherit mandate to provide quality green spaces, planting and maintaining the urban canopy, and engaging the community with regard to the benefits of trees and urban forests.
Community Services Departments – can create “green collar” jobs programs, and engage the community on the benefits of trees and urban forests.
Private Sector Organizations – can approach urban forestry on a “project by project” basis and focus on one mission at a time. Private sector organizations are also better positioned than the public sector to secure private donations.
Non-Profit Organizations -for advocacy of strategic partnerships; access to alternative funding sources; access to volunteer staff resources.
Resources for the Development of an Urban Forestry Program
“Talking Trees- An Urban Forestry Toolkit for Local Governments” November 2006 Ryan Bell and Jennie Wheeler, ICLEI-Local Governments for Sustainability
This series of six articles has investigated the various interactions and resulting benefits of the urban forest on the human condition. A healthy urban forest can help cities and municipalities achieve environmental, social, and economic sustainability goals, while reducing greenhouse gas emissions and removing carbon from the atmosphere. The urban landscape can be thought of as an urban ecosystem, with each part directly relating to and affecting the whole system. The urban forest functions in this urban ecosystem by mitigating harmful environmental issues, such as water and air pollution, and by shading and sheltering buildings with trees to reduce cooling and heating costs. In the urban environment, our health and welfare can benefit from exposure to natural settings, such as providing locations for recreation and relief from the stresses of everyday life. The benefits of trees are voluminous and immensely significant for the continued advancement of the quality of life in our rapidly-growing urban environments.
Citygreen designs and manufactures innovative structural soil cells which provide un-compacted soil to provide valuable nutrients for trees and other plants, as well as support for pavements and roads. These soil cells are a proven and effective way to promote a healthy urban forest.
Posted by Ben Gooden on Mon, Jul 29, 2013 @ 2:55 AM
by Richard J. Magill, MLA, ASLA, LEED – Magill & Associates, Inc.
Urban forestry is a multidisciplinary practice that focuses on managing and cultivating trees and green spaces within urban environments. It encompasses the planning, planting, maintenance, and conservation of trees in cities and towns. The goal of urban forestry is to create and maintain healthy, sustainable, and vibrant urban ecosystems that provide a range of ecological, social, and economic benefits. Below we’ll detail the top social benefits increasing urban green spaces brings to your community.
“People and plants are entwined by threads that reach back to our earliest experiences, as individuals and as a species”.
What are the Psychological Benefits of Urban Forestry?
A widely accepted and influential theory by S. Kaplan (1995) called Attention Restoration Theory proposes that natural environments and vegetation can assist in the functioning of human attention. Kaplan theorizes that daily life includes tasks that require long periods of directed attention, and that the execution of these tasks can be enhanced by views of nature. Urban forests provide a restorative escape from the activities that require directed attention by allowing people to rest their minds and effortlessly contemplate their environment. Studies have shown that:
People with views of nature from their work environment as less frustrated, more patient, have greater enthusiasm for their job, better health, and overall have a generally higher life satisfaction than those without contact with nature.
Those without views of nature in the workplace complain 23 percent more often of illness than those with views of nature.
Urban forests have proven to help children with Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD). A study conducted in 2001 by the Human-Environment Research Laboratory (HERL) demonstrated that ADD symptoms are more manageable after activities in green settings, and that the more a child’s everyday environment includes contact with nature, the more manageable their ADD symptoms are in general.
Trees and green urban spaces have been proven to reduce rates of depression.
What are the Health Benefits of Urban Forestry?
In addition to the psychological health benefits mentioned above, trees can also affect the physical health of a population. Kathleen Wolf at the Center for Urban Horticulture at the University of Washington has explored the idea that trees and parks can help urban dwellers to make better, more active choices about their routine activities. Ms. Wolf asserts that with an aesthetically pleasing urban forest, people are encouraged to walk in their neighborhoods during their daily activities or for recreation. This not only encourages physical activity which can help reduce obesity and weight-related diseases, but it also increases possibilities for healthy social interaction.
Other heat-related health problems, such as heat-stroke, dehydration and skin cancer are mitigated by the urban forest’s ability to moderate the temperatures created by the urban heat island. Trees can also help decrease respiratory ailments caused by air-borne pollutants by lowering pollution levels and reducing particulate matter in urban environments. Urban life can be extremely demanding often resulting in stress-related health issues. It is widely accepted that urban open spaces and parks can provide welcome relief from stress, allowing us to calm and cope, and ultimately recharge our ability to carry on.
Watch Dr. Kim Loo from Doctors for the Environment Australia speak at our ‘Where Shade hits the Pavement’ event in Penrith.
Do Urban Trees Reduce Crime?
The Human-Environment Research Laboratory has conducted multiple studies determining that trees and urban forest can actually help reduce crime. Frances Kuo and William Sullivan, the two primary researchers at HERL, suggest that trees reduce crime in two important ways.
First, frequent encounters with nature can help to sooth violent temperaments. As discussed above, trees help to mitigate mental fatigue which can cause outbursts of anger and potential violence in some people. HERL studies have shown that residents living in areas with trees use more constructive methods to deal with conflict.
Second, trees deter crime by increasing surveillance on city streets. People tend to use spaces with trees more than they use treeless spaces. Vegetation on or adjacent to streets encourages more people to use the outdoor space, thereby defending the community from crime. There is an “implied surveillance” even if people do not frequently use the vegetated space because a well-groomed neighborhood indicates that the residents care about their home and community, signaling that an intruder could be noticed or confronted. In addition, people perceive neighborhoods with blighted streetscapes and unhealthy urban forests as threatening and dangerous. Therefore, healthy urban forests can significantly decrease feelings of fear and consequently reduce incidents of crime and violence.
Does Urban Forestry improve Community Interaction?
According to HERL, a greater number of people use common spaces with trees than those without trees. People are also more inclined to spend time in common spaces as the number of trees populating those spaces rises, creating increased opportunities for positive community interaction. Furthermore, residents who actively participate in caring for trees and vegetation in outdoor common spaces are more likely to have strong social ties to their neighbors. The more residents socialize with their neighbors, the stronger the sense of community pride and identity. The urban forest provides neighborhoods with a unique and stimulating location for human social interaction.
In a series of large-scale, highly controlled field studies (Kuo and Sullivan 2003), “greener” buildings and urban forestry spaces were consistently characterized by better performance on a wide range of social ecosystem indicators. Trees and grass cover were linked with greater use of residential outdoor spaces by adults and children, healthier patterns of children’s outdoor activity, more social interaction among adults, healthier patterns of adult-child interaction and supervision, stronger social ties among adult residents, greater sense of safety and adjustment, lower levels of social disorder (such as graffiti), fewer property crimes, and fewer violent crimes. In other words, successful outdoor spaces are pivotal in the healthy social ecology of a community, and trees are a key element in creating effective outdoor spaces.
Citygreen designs and manufactures innovative structural soil cells which provide un-compacted soil to provide valuable nutrients for trees and other plants, as well as support for pavements and roads. These soil cells are an effective way to promote a healthy urban forest, and ultimately, beneficial psycho-social interaction.
We are delighted to announce we are going to be exhibiting at the ISA Conference and Trade Show promoting systems for establishing mature trees in urban areas.
METRO TORONTO CONVENTION CENTRE
TORONTO, ONTARIO, CANADA
AUGUST 3-7, 2013
The Citygreen StrataCell will be featured which is designed to highly advanced engineering specifications. StrataCell brings tree-root systems closer to pavement surfaces. Engineers have calculated that, with only 300mm of granular pavement depth, a StrataCell matrix can support maximum traffic loads.
Look out for our StrataCells in action.
We are on stand 135-137, please do come and say hello.
This is the third in a series of six articles that will explore the various interactions and outcomes that result from human contact with our urban forests. This article will investigate the impacts of our city forests on local economies.
“A healthy urban forest is one the few capital investments that municipalities can make that will actually appreciate in value over time.”
As urban forests flourish, they benefit local economies by: increasing property values, reducing healthcare costs associated with poor air quality, boosting energy savings, deferring street maintenance costs, increasing the economic stability of retail/commercial space, improving water quality, reducing stormwater runoff, and providing monetary value through marketable urban forest byproducts.
Increased Property Values
It has been well-documented that there is a positive economic effect on properties that contain, or are adjacent to, urban forests and parks. Property values increase 8-20 percent when they are adjacent to well-landscaped streets, parks, or forested open space.
Also important to local city governments is the fact that much higher property taxes are assessed on properties with higher values due to the quality and proximity of the urban forest. Municipalities also benefit from higher sales taxes when these properties are sold.
Depending on the species, maturity, location and overall quality; individual properties that contain trees are valued 5-15 percent higher than comparable properties without trees, according to the Urban Forest Institute.
Commercial rental rates increase when trees and landscaping are present. According to The Center for Urban Horticulture at the University of Washington, rates for commercial property are approximately 7 percent higher when they are adjacent to, or contain elements of, the urban forest.
There are municipalities in the United States that have seen a more than 200% return on their investment in growing and maintaining their urban forests. An example of this level of financial return is documented in the: “Benefit-Cost Analysis of Fort Collins’ Municipal Forest”, written by Gregory McPherson, James Simpson, Paula Peper, Scott Maco and Qingfu Xiao of the Center for Urban Forestry Research, Southwest Station in 2003.
Reduced Healthcare Costs
Trees can significantly decrease air pollution-related health problems in urban environments, thus decreasing the amount of money spent on health care. Urban forests also give municipalities the ability to comply with national and state standards for air pollution, which in turn saves them from having to allocate financial resources to other more expensive forms of air pollution mitigation.
In 1994 alone, the urban forest of New York City mitigated an estimated 2,007 tons of air pollution with an approximate value of 9.5 million dollars. (“A Snapshot of the Northeastern Forests”, Northeastern Area State and Private Forestry, October 2005)
Enhanced Energy Savings
With proper design considerations and minimal investment, a homeowner can reduce an energy bill by up to 25% by simply planting trees or large shrubs at key areas around the home. Tall deciduous vegetation placed on the south and west sides of a residence allows for a substantial decrease in heat buildup within the structure in summer and desirable solar gain during winter months, thus reducing energy consumption.
The LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) standards that have been developed in recent years consider the planting of trees and other vegetation around residential and commercial developments vital to their core principle of improving the energy efficiency of our built environment. The application of the LEED principles ultimately leads to considerable financial savings.
Deferred Street Maintenance Costs
Streets that are constructed with asphalt are prone to fairly rapid deterioration when the sunlight is not mitigated by shade trees or other tall vegetation. Asphalt is made of a stone aggregate and an oil binder. When asphalt is exposed to heat the oil binder volatizes and leaves the stone aggregate susceptible to degradation by weather and vehicular traffic.
The Center for Urban Forestry has found that repaving can be deferred up to 10 years on a well-shaded street and up to 25 years on a heavily-shaded street.
The findings of a study called: “Effects of Street Trees Shade on Asphalt Concrete Pavement Performance” by Gregory McPherson and Jules Muchnick published in the Journal of Arboriculture indicates that shade from large trees reduced paving costs by 58% over a 30-year period.
Stability of Retail/Commercial Economic Environments
Kathleen Wolf of the University of Washington has extensively studied the positive effects of urban forests on the economic vitality and stability of businesses. Ms. Wolf definitively states that “urban trees improve economic stability of retail environments by attracting businesses and consumers.”
It stands to reason that generously landscaped areas (canopy trees included) adjacent to retail spaces tend to set a positive mood and point to overall quality, thereby attracting consumers and increasing their rate of return.
Consumers are willing to pay up to 11% more for goods and services in business districts with trees, compared with those without trees.
In a study, “Benefits of Trees in Urban Areas” by Katherine Alexander, it was found that retail consumers give a 30% higher rating to the quality of goods, and 80% higher amenity and comfort ratings for tree-lined commercial streets.
Stormwater Benefits and Water Quality
Trees and other landscaped areas benefit cities by reducing stormwater treatment and flood control costs by reducing runoff flows. Healthy plant roots aid in improving water quality through absorption of various pollutants in surface runoff.
The city of Santa Monica, California’s street and park trees intercepted over 51 million gallons of rainfall in 2002. Approximately $111,000 in stormwater treatment and flood control costs were avoided that year due to the presence of 29,299 urban trees.
The utilization of permeable pavements and tree pit surfaces for urban tree planting allows stormwater to flow to root zones more freely for absorption. In this manner, valuable water resources are utilized more efficiently and the cost of irrigation is substantially reduced if not eliminated.
Citygreendesigns and manufactures innovative structural soil cells which provide un-compacted soil able to provide nutrients for the plants, as well as support pavements and roads. Soil cells also promote efficient stormwater management and improve water quality through increased permeability and filtration.
Marketable Forest Byproducts
There are numerous ways that cities can take economic advantage of inherent urban forest materials and associated byproducts.
Cities can make a profit by selling compromised urban trees as lumber for building materials. Many urban forests contain unique hardwoods that can be made into furniture and other consumer products. Hardwood tree species such as cherry, walnut, oak and ash are quite suitable for milling.
Excess wood from compromised trees and pruned materials can be used for firewood, thus discouraging people from heating their homes with expensive fossil fuel.
The biomass of the urban forest can be chipped and mulched for recycling into the soil. In this way, cities gain long-term value through improved plant vitality.
The economic advantages of the urban forest are quite clear and speak to an important symbiotic relationship between the health of urban plants and the health of local economies. Professional planners, urban foresters, designers, and elected officials are cognizant of this relationship, holding great promise for the future of a healthy and productive urban forest.
Next article: The Urban Forest and Social Interaction
This is the second in a series of six articles that will explore the various interactions and outcomes that result from human contact with our urban forests. This article will investigate the positive and negative impacts of our city forests on urban transportation systems.
“Urban forests (when properly designed and managed) can contribute to the enhanced safety, improved aesthetics and superior environmental conditions of our city transportation systems and our communities at large.” While this statement may seem contrary to commonly accepted transportation system planning and implementation guidelines, please consider the following.
Safety Issues
Speed Reduction- It has been proven over many years of observation that tree-lined roadways provide “spatial definition” that makes the road appear to be narrower; therefore encouraging slower driving speeds.
Stress Reduction- the psychological effect of trees along roads tends to reduce the occurrence of road rage and also improves the attention span of drivers.
Physical Buffers- Vegetation can provide an effective barrier between opposing vehicular traffic, and between adjacent public spaces and pedestrian ways.
Unwanted Obstacles- traditional road planning and design guidelines identify “clear zones” where no large objects should be allowed. Trees and other vegetation planted in these “zones” are thought of as hazards to visibility and vehicular safety. While there are certainly situations where this is absolutely true, often these guidelines are too strictly defined and applied. There are many instances where proper landscape design and plant selection would allow for trees or shrubs in or adjacent to these areas without compromising safety.
There have been a number of studies (Dumbaugh 2005, Naderi 2003 and Mok et al. 2006) that seem to indicate a decrease in crash rates on landscaped urban arterial roads and highways, versus roadways that did not have landscaped areas adjacent to them.
Aesthetic Issues
Drivers believe that forested urban highways have higher visual quality and consequently, they have more favorable perceptions of communities that contain and promote green roadsides. This subjective perception leads to a better image of these communities and results in positive socio-economic benefits beyond purely aesthetic considerations.
As alluded to in the section above, attractive trees and other vegetation planted adjacent to vehicular and pedestrian ways fosters a general sense of wellbeing and is conducive to more-positive human interaction in transportation corridors.
Environmental Issues The Good
Landscaped areas adjacent to roadways are critical to effective stormwater management, including snow storage and melting areas in colder climates. Vegetation in these areas serves to prevent unwanted erosion and helps to absorb the water that runs off of impervious roadways and associated infrastructure. Trees play a particularly important role in erosion control and absorption of surface runoff.
Properly landscaped roadways serve to filter man-made pollutants after water runs off the roads. Filtering stormwater runoff helps to keep our rivers, lakes and aquifers cleaner for human use and consumption, and ultimately protects the health of our oceans.
The shade provided by trees and other vegetation can significantly prolong the usable lifespan of roadway surfaces (particularly asphalt) by protecting them from harmful ultraviolet rays.
The “Not So Good”
Invasive tree roots can be a problem, particularly for surface streets and sidewalks where landscaping is directly adjacent to the roadway. Solutions like the Structural Soil Cells designed and manufactured by Citygreen® serve to minimize damages caused by tree root systems by providing a defined area for healthy root growth while providing exceptional structural stability for heavy-traffic areas above. Structural soil cells also improve surface drainage and play an important part in efficient stormwater management systems.
The leaves and branches from deciduous trees and shrubs can be an issue with the stormwater drainage systems of our roadways, particularly in the fall season. Regular maintenance, well-designed drainage infrastructure, and appropriate plant selection can dramatically minimize this hazard however.
Trees and shrubs adjacent to roadways, bikeways, and railroad lines can hinder visibility of other vehicles, particularly at intersections. This problem can be mitigated by good landscape planning and design, attentive pruning practices, and the timely replacement of plants that outgrow their immediate surroundings.
By utilizing a balanced response to the functional needs of transportation systems and the overall health and welfare of urban dwellers, a thoughtfully planned and managed urban forest can be the catalyst that unifies these two seemingly disparate ideals, and going forward, play a crucial role in the world’s evolving urban environment.
Next article: “The Urban Forest and Local Economies”
Posted by Ben Gooden on Sun, Apr 28, 2013 @ 5:45 AM
This is the fifth in a series of six articles that will explore the various interactions and outcomes that result from human contact with our urban forests. This article will investigate the impacts of our city forests on human health and safety.
Although these subjects were touched on in a previous article (The Urban Forest and Psycho-Social Benefits), they are such important aspects of human interaction with the urban forest, further discussion of these issues is in order.
Human Health
The Urban Forest Mitigates Air Pollution
In possibly the most important study to date on the effect of urban forests on human health, recently published on-line (June 2013) by the journal Environmental Pollution, researchers with the U.S. Forest Service and the Davy Institute in Syracuse, New York estimated how much fine particulate matter is removed by trees in 10 U.S. cities; their impact on PM2.5 concentrations and associated values, and impacts on human health. Cities included in the study were Atlanta, Baltimore, Boston, Chicago, Los Angeles, Minneapolis, New York City, Philadelphia, San Francisco, and Syracuse, NY.
The entire study, “Modeled PM2.5 Removal by Trees in Ten U.S. Cities and Associated Health Effects,” is available at: https://www.nrs.fs.fed.us/pubs/43676. This is the first effort to estimate the overall impact of a city’s urban forest on concentrations of fine particulate pollution (particulate matter less than 2.5 microns, or PM2.5). Fine particulate air pollution has serious health effects, including premature mortality, pulmonary inflammation, accelerated atherosclerosis, and altered cardiac functions.
Overall, the greatest effect of trees on reducing health impacts of PM2.5 occurred in New York due to its relatively large human population and the trees’ moderately high removal rate and reduction in pollution concentration. The greatest overall removal by trees was in Atlanta due to its relatively high percent tree cover and PM2.5 concentrations.
The study found that urban trees and forests are saving an average of one life every year per city. In New York City, trees save an average of eight lives every year.
The Urban Forest Promotes Physical Activity
Kathleen Wolf at the Center for Urban Horticulture at the University of Washington has explored the idea that trees and parks can help urban dwellers to make better, more active choices about their routine activities. Ms. Wolf asserts that with an aesthetically pleasing urban forest, people are encouraged to walk in their neighborhoods during their daily activities or for recreation. This not only encourages physical activity which can help reduce obesity and weight-related diseases, but it also increases possibilities for healthy social interaction.
Urban life can be extremely demanding often resulting in stress-related health issues. It is widely accepted that urban open spaces and parks can provide welcome relief from stress, allowing us to calm and cope, and ultimately recharge and improve overall physical health.
The Urban Forest Mitigates Other Health Issues
Other heat-related health problems, such as heat-stroke, dehydration and skin cancer are mitigated by the urban forest’s ability to moderate the temperatures created by the urban heat island.
Human Safety
The Urban Forest and Road Safety
Speed Reduction- It has been proven over many years of observation that tree-lined roadways provide “spatial definition” that makes the road appear to be narrower; therefore encouraging slower driving speeds.
Stress Reduction- the psychological effect of trees along roads tends to reduce the occurrence of road rage and also improves the attention span of drivers.
Physical Buffers- Vegetation can provide an effective barrier between opposing vehicular traffic, and between adjacent public spaces and pedestrian ways.
Unwanted Obstacles- traditional road planning and design guidelines identify “clear zones” where no large objects should be allowed. Trees and other vegetation planted in these “zones” are thought of as hazards to visibility and vehicular safety. While there are certainly situations where this is absolutely true, often these guidelines are too strictly defined and applied. There are many instances where proper landscape design and plant selection would allow for trees or shrubs in or adjacent to these areas without compromising safety.
The Urban Forest Promotes Neighborhood Security
It is widely known that urban green spaces provide many opportunities for casual social interaction and are key to the development of strong social ties. Research has indicated that neighbors who have strong social ties form more effective social groups (e.g., Greenbaum 1982; Warren 1981). Further findings suggest that residents of greener buildings feel more comfortable or adjusted in their surroundings in general. If strong social ties among neighbors are key to creating more effective, safer neighborhoods, and treed spaces help promote ties among neighbors, the presence of trees in the neighborhood landscape positively affects levels of safety and security.
Next article: The Urban Forest and Urban Planning and Policy
Citygreen® designs and manufactures innovative structural soil cells which provide un-compacted soil to provide valuable nutrients for trees and other plants, as well as support for pavements and roads. These soil cells are a proven and effective way to promote a healthy urban forest, and ultimately enhance the health and safety of residents.
Posted by Ben Gooden on Wed, Apr 10, 2013 @ 4:01 AM
This is the first in a series of six articles that will explore the various interactions and outcomes that result from human contact with our life-sustaining urban forests. These articles will explore the impacts of the urban forest on transportation, local economies, social interaction, health and safety, and urban planning and policy.
In order to better understand the impacts that our urban forests have on the human condition and conversely the effects that humans have on the forest, an introductory discussion about urban forests and urban forestry follows.
The Urban Forest
The Plants: Generally, urban forests are found in or adjacent to populated areas and are comprised of collective masses of trees, woody shrubs, annual and perennial flowers, and various types of grasses. Trees largely play the leading role in the urban forest ecosystem but certainly the other plant species play important supporting roles. Urban forests occur on both public and private lands and vary greatly in appearance. Some may be “remnant forests”: small groups of trees preserved during development that become important open space and greenbelts. Other sites are designed landscapes made up of a thoughtful composition of trees and other plants, typically found in urban parks, transitional areas (edges between different uses) and residential landscapes. Some forests thrive on undeveloped land and may be an unintended collection of plant volunteers and weedy vegetation. Even though each of the forests described above differ aesthetically and ecologically, it is widely known that trees and plants in all forms and settings provide critically important environmental benefits such as:
Sustainable Carbon Dioxide Exchange
Reduced Energy Use
Air Pollution Reduction
Storm Water Management
Water Quality Improvements
The People: The challenges that face our urban forest and its human inhabitants are vast and complex. The constraints of the forest include: limited space, soil quality, air quality, and the availability of adequate water and nutrients. These constraints significantly hinder healthy tree growth and therefore comprise the quality of life of the humans that live in urban areas.
There are many positive effects of a healthy urban forest on people, not the least of which are the psycho-social benefits. It is widely known that human interaction with nature:
Helps to Reduce Stress and Anxiety
Improves Medical Recovery and Convalescence
Contributes to Greater Job Satisfaction and Productivity
Promotes Healthy Social Interactions
Enhances Overall Quality of Life
Urban Forestry
The continued health of the urban forest is largely dependent upon the contributions of urban foresters, elected officials and policy-makers, urban designers and planners, and citizen volunteers- including residential homeowners. Obviously, the people listed above are also beneficiaries of a healthy urban forest. Perhaps this is why the movement to promote and preserve our urban forest resources has gained so much momentum in recent years.
Urban Foresters: An exciting trend in recent years is the presence of urban foresters on the staff of city governments and local agencies. These trained professionals offer critical technical knowledge of plants and their benefit to the inhabitants of urban landscapes. Even smaller municipalities are realizing the advantages of having a qualified forester to advise them on policy and procedures. Urban foresters provide important advice to local elected officials and policy-makers so that they can make informed decisions.
Elected Officials and Policy-Makers: The responsibility to turn the latest technical information and the tide of public opinion into effective policy and working regulations is largely in the hands of this group. An increased awareness of the importance of a healthy forest in all types of human interactions in the urban environment needs to be supported and advanced by these trusted public servants, both in policy and action-based regulations.
Urban Planners: Most urban planners are well versed in the importance of a healthy urban forest on the human condition. In the modern world today, planners promote the establishment and/or conservation of public and private open space, greenbelts and conservation areas, both in public community master plans and through the review of private development proposals. These trained professionals utilize the technical knowledge provided by urban foresters, sociologists, landscape architects, biologists, soil scientists, engineers and other experts to provide a framework for sustainable growth and development.
Citizens: An abundance of citizen volunteers provides a sizable workforce for planting and maintaining trees and other plants in cities and towns around the world. Without these volunteers, the cost of healthy urban forests would often be prohibitive, especially for smaller municipalities. Residential homeowners are responsible for a large portion of the urban forest and every consideration should be offered to these “volunteer foresters”, including but not limited to advantages of availability and affordability of quality plants and planting supplies at local nurseries, and favorable landscaping regulations in local governments and homeowners associations. Through the continued diligence of the volunteers who plant, maintain and support the cause of trees and other plants will further promote the health of the urban forest and insure the aesthetic and functional qualities of this important ecosystem for future generations.
Green Industry: Last but by no means least, socially and environmentally responsible companies that produce innovative products to advance the quality and efficiency of the urban infrastructure are critical the future health of our city forests. Companies such as Citygreen® produce thoughtfully designed and manufactured landscape systems, above and below ground, that provide effective solutions to the complex demands of the urban environment.
By: Richard J. Magill, Magill & Associates, Inc. & Simon Leake, Principal/Director of Operations SESL Australia
Table of Contents
It is now widely accepted by green building professionals that quality soils and healthy trees play a significant role in successful green infrastructure systems in urban environments. Trees provide a wide range of benefits to society at-large and to the urban dweller in particular.
Unfortunately, far too many urban projects across the globe are subject to entirely inadequate tree planting practices, resulting in failed or diminished results. These commonly accepted practices often lack the proper improvement of inherently poor soil, and fail to adequately address the impaired surrounding substratum, as these are the site conditions typically encountered in urban landscaping projects. Inadequate mitigation of these two important aspects in the root zone typically results in trees with less than optimal health, i.e.: severely restricted growth and habit, shortened life spans and costly re-plantings.
Why We Need Quality Soil in Urban Centres
Soil quality, also called soil health, is simply defined as: how well the soil performs and “does what we want it to do”. Specifically, soil quality is the capacity of a particular type of soil to function, within managed or natural ecosystems, to sustain plant and animal life, maintain and enhance water and air quality, and to support human health and habitation. Understanding soil quality involves the proper assessment and management of soil so it functions optimally now, and is not degraded for future use.
There are a number of factors that characterize typical urban soils and whereby reduce their productivity, such as: little or no organic matter, human artifacts that disrupt water movement, elevated salt content, interrupted nutrient cycling and modified micro-organism activity, higher pH values resulting from the introduction of cement, plaster and road salts, and compacted soil layers.
Trees need significant volumes of low-compaction soils, with suitable pore space, drainage, and organic matter to provide for long-term growth. A good rule of thumb for preserving older trees and assuring the success of new plantings in urban environments is to use large amounts of loam soils; comprised of varying percentages of sand, organic compost, and clay silt. The ratio of the ingredients listed above may vary dramatically depending on the requirements of specific plants, identified stormwater management objectives, intended land use, and the natural or man-made constraints of a particular site.
Because individual project and site conditions vary so dramatically, it is often necessary to adjust the soil ingredient mixture accordingly. Simon Leake, principal of Sidney Environmental Soils Laboratories (SESL) in Australia, favors a “Logical Approach to Soil Specification”. This approach promotes the idea that performance-based specifications are more effective than “recipe-based” soil specifications. Leake’s laboratory specifies the pH value, nutrient content, CEC (cation exchange capacity), OM (organic matter) content, permeability and whatever other properties they think necessary to compose a project-appropriate soil, rather than rely on a set recipe. These “fit for purpose” soils will optimize the water, nutrient and aeration properties to be consistent with the intended use. However, Mr. Leake cautions: “This is always a compromise between availability, cost and intended use.”
A commonly used field reference for planting soil is: two cubic feet of loam soil for every one square-foot of tree canopy (at tree maturity). Simply stated, a mature tree that provides 400 square-foot of canopy should be planted with 800 square feet of quality soil. Evidence of the benefits of using quality soil can be found in a study by the Bartlett Tree Lab. This study demonstrates that the quality loam soil grows trees that have 300 times more leaves and are 1.7 times taller than those grown in compacted soils.
Developing effective soil is a science, and it should be customized to meet individual site-demands, but it is important to point out that certain traits are universal for all quality soils, regardless of the application. These traits should include: a relatively high percolation rate to avoid prolonged surface ponding, a large capacity to sequester pollutants as water moves through it, and the nutrients necessary for vigorous plant growth.
What Role Does Soil Play in Maintaining Healthy Trees in Cities?
Soil quality plays a crucial role in maintaining healthy trees in urban environments. Trees rely on soil not only as a physical support for their roots but also as a source of essential nutrients, water, and oxygen. In urban areas, soil is often compacted due to construction, foot traffic, and other urban infrastructure activities. Compacted soil lacks the necessary pore spaces for water infiltration and root growth, which can lead to poor drainage and limited root expansion.
Healthy soil in general should have a balanced composition of minerals, organic ‘loam’ matter, oxygen, and microorganisms. This ensures the tree has proper water retention, aeration, and nutrient availability, all of which contribute to tree growth and vitality. Quality soil allows tree roots to spread, anchor securely, and access essential nutrients and water, thereby supporting overall tree health.
Without proper soil conditions, trees in urban areas may struggle to establish themselves, leading to stunted growth, reduced canopy size, and increased susceptibility to pests and diseases. Addressing soil quality is vital to ensure the long-term success of urban trees, as healthy soil directly impacts their ability to thrive amidst the challenges posed by urbanization.
Why Do Urban Trees need Different Soil Considerations than Rural Trees?
Urban trees require different soil considerations compared to rural trees due to the unique challenges posed by the urban environment. Here are several key reasons:
Soil Compaction: Urban areas often require a high level of soil compaction to support the weight of foot traffic, construction, roads, buildings, and heavy machinery. Compacted soil lacks the necessary pore spaces for air, water, and root movement, hindering root growth and nutrient absorption. leading to a poorer performing tree. Urban trees need uncompacted loamy soil that can promote healthy root development.
Limited Soil Volume: Urban trees are typically planted in small spaces like sidewalks, medians, and plazas. This limited soil volume restricts root expansion, making it essential to provide soil that can efficiently support root growth within confined areas.
Environmental Stress: Urban environments have higher pollution levels, heat island effects, and variable microclimates. Trees must cope with these stressors, requiring soil that can buffer against temperature extremes, filter pollutants, and provide optimal water and nutrient availability.
Infrastructure Interference: Underground utilities, pipes, and structures in urban areas can impede root growth and access to nutrients. Soil needs to be carefully selected and managed to accommodate these challenges while supporting tree health.
Stormwater Management: Urban trees play a vital role in stormwater runoff management, especially as Water Sensitive Urban Design (WSUD) becomes more integrated. High-quality soil combined with urban trees offer an effective method to retain water within the environment, purifying pollutants and particles from the air and water produced in urban areas.
Improving the Surrounding Substratum
The other important aspect of proper tree planting in an urban context is the condition of the underground areas (substratum) surrounding the immediate “tree pit” or “tree trench” location. Trees, and all other landscape plants for that matter, require a certain amount of lateral space underground to accommodate the biological needs of the plants for optimum root volume. Also necessary in urban streetscape situations is structural integrity and support.
The need for adequate space and soil for healthy root growth and the need for various hardscaped areas, such as sidewalks, streets, and malls, are typically at odds because paved areas demand a certain compaction below them to function properly and compacted soil severely restricts root growth. The use of quality soils is critically important for healthy trees, but without sufficient un-compacted, lateral space the root zone will be severely restricted and poor tree growth will result. The use of structural soil cells (discussed below) provides space for root growth in quality soil and the strong structural support necessary for successful urban infrastructure projects.
There have been a number of projects over the years that have utilized the “suspended pavement” approach to address the problems of poor soil and impaired substratum by constructing concrete “post and beam” structures in excavated areas and backfilling with quality soil, thus providing for structural support and adequate root growth. Unfortunately, these projects have proven to be somewhat cumbersome and quite costly.
What are Structural Soils?
In an attempt to resolve unfavorable growing conditions that arise from existing soil conditions in urban environments, Cornell University developed Structural Soils in mid-1990.
Structural soil is a mixture of stone aggregate and soil, with a small amount of polymer gel to hold the mix together. This mix can be compacted to 95% dry density and support paving and yet allow for some tree root growth.
The mix typically consists of: 20% loam soil, 80% angular gravel with no fines, and .03% polymer gel. However, structural soils have limited success for good tree growth. The main reason for this is the lack of actual soil content in the structural mix. Trees will not grow any larger than the volume of loam soil in the mix.
To create one cubic foot of usable soil under a streetscape or sidewalk, approximately five cubic feet of structural soil must be installed. This requires significant space (not usually available in urban areas) and substantial budgets (also not widely available in today’s world economy) to achieve the necessary soil volumes for healthy plant growth.
Structural Soil Cells to Improve Quality Soil in Cities
A relatively new and innovative approach to the problems associated with urban tree planting is the use of structural soil cells. These modular, pre-engineered structural cell systems, particularly those manufactured by Citygreen®, are designed to accommodate irregular urban conditions and provide 95% of the space within the cells for tree-rooting soil.
The structural cell provides for a “tree pit system” that allows for improved underground spaces for quality soils, optimum tree root volume, and superior structural support for urban hardscapes.
Structural soil cells are constructed of recycled thermoplastic material that is relatively lightweight, extremely durable, and non-toxic. The use of these materials reduces environmental impacts because they simply require less embodied energy to produce, transport and install. Recycled plastic soil cells are also more cost-effective than other systems due to lower production and shipping costs.
The structural cells also serve an important function in stormwater management because they allow water to move more freely through the root zones, and ultimately into the aquifer, as opposed to running on the surface and into overburdened urban stormwater management systems. These cellular systems are proving to be much more efficient and cost-effective than previous approaches.
Water Starved Tree
Quality soil and using it to fill the matrix
Soil Analysis
Conclusion
Quite often trees are planted without quality loam soil and are “squeezed” into places that lack the proper space to develop healthy root structure. In the past, designers and engineers failed to address this problem and simply hoped for the best, not knowing the actual biological and physical requirements of the plants. This of course resulted in multitudes of failed tree plantings across the world and unfortunately continues in some areas.
Simon Leake of SESL points out that there have been a number of advances in soil technology in recent years, including:
“Gap-graded” soils that cope with compaction issues from increasing population and resulting uses. “Gap-graded” means that in the particle size grading there is a “gap” where no or few particles of a certain size exist, whereby insuring that there is sufficient pore space in the soil to resist compaction from pedestrian or other traffic. These soils are specified by the United States Golf Association for heavily trafficked turf areas, such as greens and tees, and are increasingly employed by sports field designers and urban parks, because they have better water and nutrient-holding capabilities, and improved compaction resistance.
Less use of “structural soils”. Even though these “soils” continue to have their applications, they only contain 20% of useful soil for root zone volume. Structural soil cell systems like those manufactured by Citygreen, are much more effective for optimal tree growth in urban situations. Soil cells allow for the use of quality, non-compacted loam soils, and provide the root-zone space necessary for vigorous tree growth.
Improvement of urban stormwater runoff management by using sandy filtration-type soils to improve water quality for irrigation and other uses.
Promotion of stormwater harvesting through the use of gap-graded soils that filter the runoff prior to discharge or storage. Filtered stormwater can be directed from street drains and culverts to tree pits whereby significantly reducing irrigation and maintenance.
Today, green urban design and building professionals better understand the need for quality soil and improved substratum for healthy tree growth in difficult urban environments. But even armed with this knowledge, trees are often planted improperly due to design constraints, budgetary issues, and substandard installation practices. It is important that design guidelines that require the use of site-specific quality soil and innovative structural support systems be considered and adopted into the local building codes to insure that the use of appropriate materials becomes standard operating procedure for urban landscaping projects. Increased diligence by all of the key decision-makers in the approval, design, and installation of urban infrastructure will promote the use of quality soils and innovative support structures to insure the future long-term success of our urban forests.
About the Authors
Richard J. Magill, MLA, ASLA, LEED Green Associate Magill & Associates, Inc. Landscape Architecture and Planning Aspen, Colorado 81611
Simon Leake, B Sc (Ag) ASSSI SESL Australia Principal/Director of Operations Thomleigh, NSW 1715
“Great customer service, quick response times and a very in depth QA system with constant support.”
- Laura Wiesenekker, Project Engineer, Densford Civil -
“Citygreen is a very professional business, and I found everything was great in terms of deliveries, product supply and information. It was all forthcoming and helped us to complete the project.”
- Keith Burns, Architect/Designer, Keith Burns Architect -
“Citygreen offered training and invaluable technical assistance during the works.”
- James Callan, Estimating Manager, Complex Co Pty Ltd -
“Our experience, in working with a Citygreen Design Studio was second to none. We found responses from the design studio to be very timely, and technically thorough. We went backwards and forwards a number of times, looking at different iterations of the design and, nothing was too much trouble to examine and explore different possibilities. I would highly recommend the Citygreen Design Studio to any future client considering using your services.”
- Sandra Smith, Principal Landscape Architect, City Of Monash -
“We are big on compliance on all projects, and the fact that their SmartCertify cloud platform covers all bases, and supports their 20 year warranties, is critical – especially that these pits are being installed under roadways and footpaths.”
- Johny Purkaystha, Civil Program Engineer, Central Coast Council -
"I reviewed all the previous projects that we have installed in the past couple years using your product and I can happily report back that we have 0% mortality in the soil cells, which is incredible!"
- Brendan Wilton, CEO, Trim Landscaping, Bedford, Canada -